Discussing the NSA TURBINE initiative with Rick Cluff on CBC Radio Vancouver’s Early Edition
All posts by Jesse Hirsh
The Culture of Lawlessness in DC: Why Sen. Dianne Feinstein Declared War on the CIA
The Culture of Lawlessness in DC: Why Sen. Dianne Feinstein Declared War on the CIA
This story has a simple message: The system that is supposed to maintain the balance between secrets and civil liberties has broken down. Many believed that it already had, but Feinstein, for good reason, had argued that even if changes needed to be made, the essential relationship between her committee and the agencies it oversees was operating within bounds. What she described Tuesday was a total lack of trust on both sides. The level of trust was so low that people may have felt it was necessary to break the law to fulfill their obligations. That’s not just bad for this particular relationship; it throws the balance between the two branches into even greater turmoil than it was already in.
Blushing as an asset and sign of trust
Blushing as an asset and sign of trust
To blush is to be human, vulnerable, and humble to the power of the subconscious. This BBC article synthesizes a series of studies on how, why, and what happens when we blush. In particular it focuses on the social impact of blushing, and the trust it often engenders from those observing the blush.
As we move further into an automated, robotic, and fast paced society, the inherently human characteristics we can all exhibit will and are already becoming more powerful. We desire authenticity, and we demand transparency of our leaders, perhaps the blush is a means of cultivating these qualities.
Erotic Capital And The End Of Men
I recently finished reading, and thoroughly enjoyed, Hanna Rosin’s book “The End of Men”. I chose to read this book after watching her RSA talk, and while reading the book, CBC Radio’s Ideas, broadcast the Munk Debates that were on the same subject.
As a man I’m neither threatened nor intimidated by the concept that the dominance of men in our society is in decline, or that women are rising in power, either independently, or even at the expense of most men. I see gender as a dynamic and often limiting concept, that is best experienced in the most flexible and self-defined terms.
I also agree with Hanna’s argument that women are rising, and that men are in decline. Many if not most of the men I’ve known in my life have struggled to find a meaningful and contributing role for themselves in this society. School was almost impossible to complete, and meaningful work is rarely found and never secure.
I constantly struggle to understand what it means to be a man in our world, and while I have great role models in my family, I find the landscape of pop culture littered with men I cannot identify with, and find myself wanting to be the opposite of. There are few who I’ve been able to look to as role models, and almost all of them are people I’ve known personally, and thus not part of pop culture per se.
Instead I’ve consistently found myself looking to women as role models. As the leaders I want to follow and take cues from. Professionally I’ve sought out strong female leaders to support and collaborate with.
In particular Hanna Rosin cites Julie Gerberding on the concept of meta-leadership or horizontal leadership. This involves knowing how to negotiate, collaborate, employ emotional intelligence and empathy. These traits are not exclusive to women, but they’re often not what men focus on when defining their own leadership styles.
Similarly another concept worth exploring is the theory of erotic capital, as developed by Catherine Hakim. Erotic capital is a “fourth personal asset” that compares to economic, cultural, and social capital. Hanna Rosin refers to erotic capital as charm and charisma rather than beauty or sexiness.
As Catherine Hakim argues, erotic capital is not only important when it comes to mating and marriage, but also labour markets, the media, politics, advertising, sports, the arts, and everyday social interaction. She also notes that women often have more erotic capital simply because they spend more time cultivating and using it. This is in spite of attempts by male dominated societies to impose moral ideologies and restrictions on the ability of women to employ and exploit their erotic capital for economic and social benefits.
There are many men who express resentment at the way women are now able and free to properly wield and explore their erotic capital. Instead as men we can learn how to better develop and understand our own erotic capital. The same way we can develop and understand feminine models of leadership and governance.
Rosin similarly describes the financial benefit many companies have found by discarding public corporate identities and brands which were exclusively male, with ones that were more inclusive:
“Companies no longer wanted to present themselves as faceless arbiters of authority; in an increasingly democratic, multicultural age they wanted to be seen as approachable and consumer responsive… Now in the era of self-expression and social media, stone-faced patriarchy is the kiss of death.”
Thus one of the primary messages men can take from this book is to be able to adapt, and be malleable. We live in a dynamic world where the rapid rate of technological change means that lifelong learning and multiple careers are how things will be for most if not all.
Women are succeeding because they are able to adapt, manage multiple roles, often multiple jobs, and the expectations that come with juggling life, work, family, and friends.
The good news for men is that with enough humility, there are an ample supply of nearby potential teachers and role models to learn from.
Narcissism Drives The Desire For Fame
Cognitive psychologist Scott Barry Kaufman, writing for Scientific American, highlights interesting research around the motivations for fame, and the role of narcissism.
The first study was by John Maltby, who looked at what motivates 10-12 year olds desire for fame:
- Intensity (e.g., “Very little matters to me apart from being famous”)
- Vulnerability (e.g., “I want to be famous because it would help me overcome issues I have about myself”)
- Celebrity Life-Style (e.g., “I want to be rich”)
- Drive (e.g., “I work hard everyday to be famous”)
- Perceived Suitability (e.g., “I have got what it takes to be famous”)
- Altruistic (e.g., “I want to be famous so I can make a contribution to society”)
The second study was led by Dara Greenwood, building off of Maltby’s work, focusing in on the reasons why people want fame:
- The desire to be seen/valued (e.g., “Being on the cover of a magazine”, “Being recognized in public”)
- The desire for an elite, high status lifestyle (e.g., “Having the ability to travel in first class and stay at exclusive resorts”, “Living in a mansion or penthouse apartment”)
- The desire to use fame to help others or make them proud (e.g., “Being able to financially support family and friends”, “Being a role model to others”)
While on the one hand I’ve often regarded the desire for fame as a desire for power, this research suggests that it is also a means of self-fulfillment. That for narcissists, fame may be their ultimate goal, the justification for their narcissism, as an aspirational self-fulfilling prophecy. Maybe the individual who wants to be famous thinks that if they are even more narcissistic their chance of fame will increase.
The research also touches upon the “need to belong”, which Scott Barry Kaufman uses to argue that the desire for fame is “rooted in basic human needs”.
While I acknowledge that the desire for community and connection is strong when it comes to motivating people, I’m not sure it should be regarded in this manner. Rather I wonder if that desire for fame actually subverts and hurts a subject’s need for belonging.
In wanting to belong, they seek fame, embracing narcissism, and potentially alienating the people who would otherwise care for and accept them. The paradox of social relations in the era of social media is that while the tools could be used for social connection, they are more often used in the pursuit of fame via narcissistic over-sharing.
Hacking Reality
I was invited to give a TEDx talk at Western University and I decided to present some of the knowledge that has emerged via the Hacking Reality program at the Academy of the Impossible. Explicitly I focused on how the internet impacts our relationship with authority, and as a result our relationship with reality. The opportunity therefore is to hack reality, and demand the impossible.
If you find it entertaining please share widely.